Friendship and community in plato's lysis author(s): mary p nichols source: the review of politics, vol 68, no 1 (winter, 2006), pp 1-19 my essay on plato's lysis is divided into three parts the first examines the case for understanding philosophy as the true friendship that individuals. Plato had used these works to describe socrates at his best and was meant to be studied by the academy created by socrates lysis & socrates: what is friendship essay lysis & socrates: what is friendship socrates shows this by starting a debate with lysis and menexenus about friendship. Lysis & socrates: what is friendship we will write a custom essay sample on lysis & socrates: what is friendship for only $1390/page (plato, bibb) nexuses claims there to be no difference at all, and it is possible for two people to be friends if only one loves the other. The book also provides fresh interpretations of works on friendship by plato, cicero, epicurus, seneca, montaigne and bacon the author shows how each of these thinkers sheds light on central questions of moral philosophy: is human sociability rooted in neediness or strength is the best life chiefly solitary, or dedicated to a community with.
Friendship, as understood here, is a distinctively personal relationship that is grounded in a concern on the part of each friend for the welfare of the other, for the other’s sake, and that involves some degree of intimacy. And so, lysis and menexenus, we have discovered the nature of friendship-- there can be no doubt of it: friendship is the love which by reason of the presence of evil the neither good nor evil has of the good, either in the soul, or in the body, or anywhere. Inside, socrates, lysis, and lysis's friend menexenus sit down to talk socrates convinces lysis that he is currently a slave to his parents, and that the only way out of this situation is through greater knowledge and understanding.
Models of love and friendship in plato’s lysis one of the aspects of this dialogue which creates difficulties for students approaching it for the first time is that there are multiple notions of love or friendship brought up within the dialogue – but socrates and his interlocutors don’t really distinguish between them when they are working them out or referring to them. Eaton 1 william eaton friendship, deception, writing: within and beyond plato’s lysis 1 plato’s dialogue the lysis concerns friendship, and it is possible that it is this—friendship—that has, above all, eluded and frustrated scholars. The subject was puzzling to them: they could not say that friendship was only a quality, or a relation, or a virtue, or a kind of virtue and they had not in the age of plato reached the point of regarding it, like justice, as a form or attribute of virtue. Do opposites attract please do not copy this report it is unethical, immoral, and just plain wrong to copy my work i have provided it on the net so that the whole world can learn from some of the research i have done it doesn't do anyone any good sitting on my hard drive.
And so, lysis and menexenus, we have discovered the nature of friendship — there can be no doubt of it: friendship is the love which by reason of the presence of evil the neither good nor evil has of the good, either in the soul, or in the body, or anywhere. Plato’s lysis takes on the issue of friendship and what, in essence, makes one a friend socrates encounters a group of boys who lead him to begin the discussion, in the effort to show hippothales how he might act toward his beloved, lysis, so as not to drive him away but rather to draw him closer. Friendship, such as that enjoyed between lysis and menexenus, is the topic addressed within this context socrates considers a number of hypotheses about friendship, shifting a bit from an attempt to describe what person (or role) is the true friend to trying to find the universal cause of desire. What is friendship this is the question pondered in lysis by plato a review of benjamin jowetts translation-jake e stief the long haired freaky dude.
The account of eros—roughly, desire—in the symposium appears to fail, and, though the lysis contains much suggestive material for an account of philia—roughly, friendship—this is an aporetic dialogue, which fails, ultimately, to provide an account of friendship. It involves two characters, lysis and menexenus including hippothales (the guy who is in love with the boy, lysis) the greek word philia here is equated, possibly the nearest, with the literal english word friendship. The phaedrus (greek: φαῖδρος), written by plato, is a dialogue between plato's main protagonist, socrates, and phaedrus, an interlocutor in several dialogues the phaedrus was presumably composed around 370 bc, around the same time as plato's republic and symposium. Plato's dialogue on friendship: an interpretation of the lysis, with a new translation, trans david bolotin (cornell, on plato's lysis, the argument of the action: essays on greek poetry and philosophy, ed ronna burger and michael davis,. Ing friendship -of realizing it and also of realizing what it is- al1 along the three discourses that plato's lysis offers us with this, we believe that we will be able.
Plato's dialogue on friendship david bolotin: plato's dialogue on friendship an interpretation of the lysis with a new translation pp 227 ithaca and london: cornell university press, 1979 £750. Plato was born c 427 bc in athens, greece, to an aristocratic family very much involved in political government pericles, famous ruler of athens during its golden age, was plato's stepfather plato was well educated and studied under socrates, with whom he developed a close friendship. Lysis is a dialogue of plato which discusses the nature of friendship it is generally classified as an early dialogue the main characters are socrates, the boys lysis and menexenus who are friends, as well as hippothales, who is in unrequited love with lysis and therefore, after the initial conversation, hides himself behind the surrounding. “lysis,” written by plato in approximately 380 bce (the exact year is unknown) is an in depth look, through the teachings of socrates, at the nature of friendship, desire, usefulness and personal identity.
Lysis on friendship, philosophy audiobook by plato, classic greek philosopher on friendship, philosophy audiobook by plato, classic greek philosopher skip navigation friendship, an essay. Numerous commentators have highlighted the centrality of lysis's silence in the passage and in the interpretation of the dialogue as a whole (gonzalez, “plato's lysis,” 84 gadamer, dialogue and dialectic, 19 tindale, “plato's lysis,” 106–107 and bolotin, plato's dialogue on friendship, 186–187) they all agree that his silence is. Plato discusses love (erôs) and friendship (philia) primarily in two dialogues, the lysis and the symposium, though the phaedrus also adds significantly to his viewsin each work, socrates as the quintessential philosopher is in two ways center stage, first, as a lover of wisdom (sophia) and discussion (logos), and, second, as himself an inverter or disturber of erotic norms. Lysis, or friendship persons of the dialogue: socrates, who is the narrator, menexenus, hippothales, lysis, ctesippus scene: a newly-erected palaestra outside the walls of athens i was going from the academy straight to the lyceum, intending to take the outer road, which is close under the wall.